This was a dusty old post from the archives that I wrote nearly 9 years ago, and darn it this pie is so good that I wanted to give it a refresh and truly do it justice in a second go-round. If you’ve never had or heard of chess pie before, it hails from the southern states and its main characteristics are that it’s 1) a baked custard, and 2) has corn meal as the thickening agent in the custard instead of flour. Over the years of making this chocolate chess pie, I’ve started pulsing the corn meal in a blender or food processor to get it nice and fine, since most of the cornmeal you find at the store is coarsely ground and more geared towards polenta or heavy-crumbed cornbreads. Those few minutes of pulsing that corn meal into a fine powder have made all the difference in upping the silkiness factor of this custard base, and I highly recommend taking the few seconds to do so.
I’m a bit obsessed with salted chocolate, so I sprinkled some flakey sea salt over the pie once it was done, and the nice salted crunch against the sweet chocolate filling was very, very good. It’s a very small step that makes all the difference in terms of flavor and texture. And you probably noticed, but I dressed up the top a bit by making a crescent shape out of some extra pie crust dough. I have all the details on how to do this in the recipe below, and don’t worry, it’s a lot easier than it looks (don’t you just love things that look fancy but aren’t actually that difficult? I know I do!)
I hope you enjoy the recipe, my friends, and that it gives you something cozy and comforting to enjoy during the cold months ahead. Oh! And one more thing. The original post has a verrrrrry old giveaway in it for a set of cookbooks, and one of the entry requirements was to leave a comment about your favorite cookbook. So if you scroll down to the comments section, there’s LOADS of amazing cookbook recommendations for your viewing pleasure (maybe you can find some Christmas gift ideas in there, too!)
Chocolate Chess Pie
Ingredients
Chocolate Chess Pie Filling
- 2 Eggs beaten
- 5 ounces Evaporated Milk
- 1 Cup White Sugar
- 1/4 Cup Brown Sugar
- 1/4 Cup Cocoa Powder
- 1/4 Cup Butter melted
- 2 Tablespoons Finely Ground Corn Meal (Can pulse normal corn meal in a blender or food processor to make it extra fine)
- 1 Teaspoon Vanilla Extract
- 1 1/2 Teaspoons Flake sea salt, such as maldon salt
Pie Crust
- 2 3/4 Cups Flour
- 2 Tablespoons Granulated Sugar
- 1/2 Teaspoon Salt
- 8 ounces Unsalted Butter very cold
- 9 to 12 Tablespoons of Ice Water
- 1 egg
- 1 teaspoon milk
Instructions
Pie Crust
-
Grease the pie pan, place it upside down on top of a piece of paper, and trace the circumference of the pan. Then nudge the pan a few inches to the side to reveal a crescent shape in the tracing. Trace the edge of the pan to create the crescent shape. Place the pan right side up again and set it aside.
-
In a large bowl, mix together the flour, sugar, and salt until combined. Using a box grater, grate the butter using the large hole setting of the grater above the bowl, stopping to stir and coat the butter bits in the flour mixture every 10 seconds or so. When all the butter is in, pinch the mixture together with your fingertips until it resembles the texture of damp sand. Add the water, a tablespoon at a time, mixing it with a fork, until the dough just holds together when you squeeze a fistful of it in your hand.
-
Divide the dough into two portions, one slightly larger than the other (about 1/3 vs 2/3). Roll out the larger quantity of dough until it is 1 cm thick and transfer it to the greased pie pan. Press the crust into the pan, trim off the excess leaving a 1-inch overhang. Fold the 1-inch overhang under the edge of the crust all the way around and pinch the edges. Cover and place the pan in the freezer for 30 minutes.
-
Roll out the smaller dough until it's 1 cm thick. Cut out the traced crescent and place it over the dough. Use a pizza cutter, pastry cutter, or sharp paring knife to cut out the crescent shape. Discard the paper. Use cookie cutters or pie cutters to cut out more decorative shapes, or you can cut them out of the dough by hand with a knife.
-
In a small bowl, whisk together the egg and milk to create the egg wash. Place a piece of parchment paper on a small baking sheet and place the crescent on top of it. Brush it lightly with the egg wash, and brush any decorative cut-outs with the egg wash. Arrange the decorative cut-outs on the crescent, and place the pan in the freezer for 45 minutes.
Chocolate Chess Pie
-
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, mix together the granulated sugar, brown sugar, cornmeal, and cocoa powder at low speed. Add the eggs, one at a time, and mix until fully incorporated. Then mix in the evaporated milk, butter, and vanilla extract until completely combined.
-
For the top decoration, place the baking sheet with the crescent on it in the oven and bake at 350 degrees until golden, about 30 minutes (it can be in the oven at the same time as the pie that follows). Allow the crescent to cool to room temperature.
-
Pour the filling into the prepared pie crust and bake on the second lowest rack of the oven until the filling is set around the edges and the center has a *very* small wiggle to it, about 1 hour to 1 hour 10 minutes. (If the crust is browning too quickly, cover the edges with tin foil but don't let the tin foil touch the filling). Remove from the oven and allow to cool for 30 minutes before sprinkling with the flake sea salt, garnishing the top with the crescent, slicing the pie, and serving.
I think my favorite cookbook is my classic fannie farmer cookbook! it has a lot of really great, timeless recipes.
this is a GREAT giveaway! i hope i win! 🙂
rlahardison at gmail dot com
Subscribed via email using hardison dot rachael at yahoo dot com.
thanks for the chances!
My favorite cookbooks is one that came from the church that my grandparents went to. Lot's of old traditional recipes and Hungarian goodies.
Sleepyheadedmom at gmail dot com
This is a wonderful recipe and much easier than another one I used occasionally. Thank you sooo much!
My favorite cookbook is one I got in my hometown in an old opera house used bookstore called The Williamsburg Art of cooking. It's super old and has even older recipes!
I am also subscribed via google reader.
heather says: my favorite cookbook is one my mother gave to me. This pie looks delish thank you for the wonderful giveaway I pray I win it.
hg temp addy at hot mail dot com
My favorite cookbook is one that I typed up and printed for my parents 50th wedding anniversary. Mom was a great cook and it's full of her recipes and my sisters and I also contributed recipes for it. I use it all the time. The giveaway looks amazing – I started to say especially a certain book but no, all of the books.
My favorite cookbook is the one I made when my sister got married full of family recipes.
I already subscribe to your RSS feed in my Google Reader.
My favorite cookbook is my culinary school baking book … best, EVER cookbook!!!
I subscribe your blog via. Google Reader 🙂
My (current) favorite cookbook is Bake it in a Cupcake!
I subscribe via Google Reader.
My favorite cookbooks are the Sprouted Kitchen book and Heidi's Supernatural books. (I couldn't pick just one!)
I just subscribed via e-mail.
My favorite cookbooks are the ones you used to get from the school. All the parents would put together their favorite recipes and then you could purchase them for a small fee. Wonderful recipes!
I also subscribe to the RSS feeds and also email.
What awesome books to be giving away! My favorite cookbook right now is the Smitten Kitchen cookbook! The Pie it Forward also looks awesome, though!
I also subscribe vie RSS feed!
My favorite cookbook is my Good Housekeeping Cookbook.
I'm an email subscriber
this looks delicious dear.. i'm gonna try it soon!
wish you happy new year 🙂
xxxFiC.
I love "homemade" it's a great book. I already subscribe, but I would love to win!!
Ohh I have so many cookbooks, there is no way I could pick a favorite – I love them all!! 🙂
I already subscribe via email!
I love my children's elementary school fund raiser cookbook. I have tried and love so many of the recipes entered by student's parents.
Definitely both of Pioneer Woman's cookbooks!
I already subscribe to Adventures in Cooking via e-mail.
I love the Joy of Cooking. I use it most often to answer questions that come up from recipes on blogs or in other cookbooks. It is my go to source for conversions, substitutions, and just verifying basics of any recipe.
I am already a subscriber via email!
I am already a subscriber via facebook and pinterest too!
My favorite cookbook is The Pioneer Woman Cooks
Confirmed email subscriber
I love the Fannie Farmer cookbook. It was like a history of American cooking. As a lover of cooking and history, it was perfection for me.
I'm an email subscriber!
I love the taste of home cookbooks.
I am an email subscriber!
I also follow via pinterest too! 🙂
I subscribe via email and I love pie!
My favorite cookbook is Cotton Country Cooking, by the Junior League of Monroe, Georgia. Southern, French, and cajun recipes. I got my first copy in the early 70s, it's been republished many times since.
Pie is one of my favorite things, and I'm not good at it – I'd love to win one of these books! I'm already a subscriber!
I wonder if a bit of egg wash under the rope would help?
I have this cookbook in my kitchen: Kitchen Life: Real Food For Real Families — Even Yours! because it has great recipes that don't take too long and don't have too many ingredients. Thanks!
I am also a subscriber 🙂
I just subscribed via email.
Also, I don't think that I could choose a favorite cookbook! They are my babies, and I have them on a bookshelf over my bed where I can look at them as I drift off to sleep. But either my Marion Cunningham-edited Fannie Farmer cookbook, or, currently, Carol Benner Dolp's Great Coffee Cakes, Sticky Buns, and More could be considered the favorite.
Leslie:
I enjoy the fundraiser type cookbooks. My favorite is one put together by the ladies of my church back in the 70's.
leslieannstevenson@yahoo.com
Leslie:
I subscribe via email.
leslieannstevenson@yahoo.com
I'm a Fannie Farmer kind of girl! This looks insane… in a good way.
Hello! This cake looks delicious and definitely a must bake!!
About your lovely rolled crust falling into your cake… I think it would stay in place if you secured it with toothpicks (that have been broken in half maybe), just a few. Or maybe if you painted the border with a little karo corn syrup, which has glue-like qualities. Thank you for the lovely post!!
1. This recipe looks AMAZING and I am going to make it for my bff who is coming to visit on Wednesday..
2. I want ALL of those books! Super fun, my fiance and I just started getting into canning and we love it!
Thanks for the fun give-away and great pie recipe!
I forgot to list my favorite cookbook! It is Chicken and Egg: A Memoir of Suburban Homesteading – my lovely Mom gave me this cookbook and it is awesome! The cucumber egg salad recipe is probably my favorite egg salad recipe ever.
I am also a big fan because I love chickens and prior to our move to the Bay Area I had a flock of five back yard hens that I LOVED. I still miss those ladies…
gorgeous pie!!
fave craft is my photography!
I love our family farmers garden, in southern Minnesota with 900 acres of veggies and fruit!
Firebirdie_77@hotmail.com
My favorite cookbook for LAUGHS is "Have Cookbook Will Marry" You have to laugh or you will cry at how mainstream the 1950's image of a 'good' wife were and are. But it has my all time favoriet brownies recipe. My Got To is Mark Bittman How to cook everything. I have cooked for decades and still learn new stuff every time I open his book. Thanks for the great PIX and giveaway.
I came for the chocolate pie and stayed for the giveaway 🙂 Great selection of books! AND delicious looking pie!
My favourite garden book so far is "Der Biogarten" by Marie-Luise Kreuter – lots of information on organic gardening.
My favorite cookbook is "Bake the Bread, Buy the Butter" by Jennifer Reese, it tells you what's worth your time to make on your own and what's just not even worth the effort! It's a realistic take on homemade cooking.
Love this recipe! Can't wait to try it, the photos make it look so delicious!
This pie looks so good. I was a pie-hater when I was a kid (what the heck, right?), but I always made an exception for chocolate pie. (:
(Also, Johnny bought me the Bouchon Bakery cookbook for Christmas, so that's my current obsession. Yet another heavy, slighty intimidating cookbook that I want to make every single thing from!)
Other than cooking my favorite craft is jewelry making. I especially like hammering raw steel into beautiful necklaces accented with lovely beads. I am just learning and it is challenging.
I love my America's Test Kitchen cookbook.
For everyday cooking, my go-to is the Joy of Cooking. Right now I'm cooking through the Joy the Baker Cookbook.
I just subscribed to your RSS feed!
Oooh, I have so many favorites it`s hard to choose! My favorite gardening book might be Sepp Holtzer`s Permaculture, it`s a bit on the larger scale of gardening, into farming, but it`s very inspiring.
I also subscribe via google reader (is that subscribing? I dunno, but I love seeing your beautiful food photography in each post!)
My favorite cookbooks are the ones that the local churches put out each year as fundraisers…great old timey recipes!
sherri419 at gmail dot com
My copy of Victory Garden is my favorite. I had to replace it recently as it fell apart from too much reading.Your photos are gorgeous!
My favorite cookbook is "Bitterwsweet" by Alice Medrich.
Favorite cookbook is probably Veganomicon by Isa Chandra Moscowitz and Terry Hope Romero. Great recipes for cooking grains, veggies, and legumes that are occasionally forgotten. Love the blog! Cheers
I used to work at a pie shop where we served this, but I've never seen a recipe for it otherwise! I love your images! My favorite cookbooks is Baking by Dorie Greenspan – an awesome, awesome baking book!
I am a subscriber.
My favorite cookbook(s) is still my mother's 1969 collection of the Woman's Day encyclopedia (I guess if you put them all together, it would be one big book:-) I would love to add any of these to my collection!
Omg this sounds great, looks good too 🙂
My favorite cookbook is Better Homes and Gardens Big Book of 30-Minute Dinners and Betty Crocker's Quick and Easy. I love all cookbooks, though, and I have tons of them! And I want more!
Digicats {at} Sbcglobal {dot} Net
I subscribed to your newsletter via e-mail.
Digicats {at} Sbcglobal {dot} Net
I like our local elementary school's cookbook
My favourite cookbook is our family cookbook. Ever since I can remember I was interested in cooking and I typed up all these recipes, the way the food is made in our family. So if you want chicken soup, there are at least four entries (Mum, Grandma, Auntie and me). It's a very used book, I should probably stitch it together really soon, but it's a true walk down all of our lives.
this pie is fantastic, eva! the pictures are darkly stunning as well. my favorite cookbook right now is martha stewart's cupcake book–so far, it contains about 90% winners! 🙂
Lovely pie…I love chocolate.I´m from Argentina.My favorite cookbook is Cocinando con la señora Siemienzuk,de Nilda de Siemienzuk.In English,I like Martha Stewart and Jamie Olivier.I like tradicional cook.Mirian.
Your photographs are gorgeous.
My favorite cookbook is one that my daughter made me of all our family favorites with pictures. Love it! The book I use the most would probably be Silver Palate Cookbook. Everything I made from that book was delicious…always wish it had pictures though.
Hi
My favorite cookbook is Goodhouse Keeping cookbook.
Thank you for the lovely giveaway.
Blessings
Christine T
cteo23@ gmail.com
Hi
I subscribed thru email.
Thank you
Christine T
cteo23@gmail.com
I love all the Barefoot Contessa cookbooks!
Thanks,
Amanda
ano5m@virginia.edu
I'm loving my Modern Greek cookbook.
rugerpuppies at hotmail dot com
My favorite cookbook is probably La Tartine Gourmande because of her beautiful pictures!
My favorite cookbook is "From Mom With Love…" By Pushpa Bhargava. I had never even tried Indian food before my husband gave me this book. Now I have made almost everything in it. I have written and spilled so much all over this book that I may need a new copy. Now I am getting into Middle Eastern and more Asian cooking. A good cookbook opens your eyes to things you never knew existed much less LOVE!
I just subscribed!
It's hard to say what my favorite cookbook or craft or garden book is because nowadays it's so much easier for us to look up things on the internet, but there is definitely something great about holding a book in your own two hands, and having a physical collection of recipes you can flip through. I just found a few great cookbooks at a used book store that I really liked, one is called "Pies: Recipes, History, and Snippets," and the other is a recipe book from Sweden which has so many lovely classic Swedish recipes that was published in the 70's.
Thanks for the great recipe! And the books look great!!!
My favorite cookbook is definitely vegan soul kitchen. It's brought me new inspiration in trying to make healthier food. But sometimes a girl just needs to make a buttery pie. Beautiful photography on this post!!
My favourite cookbook is a "cook everything" book that I got from my mother…it's from her mother…(my gramma) It's a Polish cookbook…full of lovely Polish recipes and pictures 🙂
-Monika
Beautiful cookbooks! My favorite cookbook is Good to the Grain by Kim Boyce, because I use it so often and there are so many pretty recipes.
This is my first time here… I followed a photo of this pie in hope there would be a recipe with it and look what I have found. Gorgeous photographs and all with recipes too *hungry huge eyes* I subscribed immediately 😀
I can't possibly point out just one craft book or cookbook :/ I have several and each time I take one out I find it so inspirational… well, it's the reason why we have them in the first place anyway, right? 🙂
I can tell you that the last cookbook I ordered was Hamlyn's All Colour Cookbook 200 Christmas Recipes and amongst all the crafty ones I got Scandinavian Needlecraft is very close to my heart.
I hope this will count.
Thank you for this great opportunity and I wish you a very bright and happy 2013!
My favorite cookbook is my Huntsville Heritage Cookbook. I have been married almost 30 years and this was my first wedding present. It is from the Junior League of my hometown, Huntsville, Alabama, and it is full of the most scrumptious southern recipes that make your mouth water. Occasionally, I run across a recipe from someone I knew in my childhood, which is very comforting. Thank you for letting me share… Lynn
This chess pie really does look delicious. I've made chess pie, and I've made chocolate pie. But I haven't made a chocolate chess pie…yet….but I'm pretty sure after reading this, that it WILL be the NEXT pie I made. And ya know, I'm a crust girl, so the idea of the extra (fallen-over braid part) crust being baked into the filling, I really kinda like it! It's kind of cool looking. 🙂 This isn't the giveaway post, this is just a response to your beautiful chocolate chess pie. 🙂 Thanks!
~Joy from Yesterfood
My favorite cook book right now is Vintage Cakes by Julie Richardson. My baking group is baking from it this year. YUM. 🙂
I have subscribed via email! Thanks for the great giveaway! 🙂
Wow that's a lot of comments! Just came to you from Lora… that mad hausfrau:-) The nougatine spoke to me. I recently did a post on Gesine and her Starry starry night cookies. She's somebody I think would be fun to know. And I think you'd like her home and animals- not to mention her confections and certified kitchen. Thanks and lovely to stop by here. wendy
I love my Elana's Pantry gluten free almond flour cookbook.
lovelydomesticdiva (at) gmail (dot) com
The pie looks amazing!!! I love gardening tomatoes. Only because I can't raise chocolate:) My favorite cookbook is the one my mother made for our family. (of course) Subscribing now!
What a beautiful looking pie.
I tend to use my Complete Vegetarian more often then not and supplement with allrecipes!
Thank you for the opportunity!
My favorite cookbook is Julia Child's Mastering the Art of French Cooking. Thank you for the giveaway!
chaunguyen312 (at) yahoo (dot) com
– Chau
I just made a chess pie over the holidays so I'm curious to try this version as well. My favorite cookbook has to be Mark Bittman's How to Cook Everything. I find that I turn to it all the time when I have something in the fridge that I need to use up (right now it's broccoli and carrots!).
While I can gaze for hours at any cookbook, I find the Moosewood series to be a go-to for everyday recipes.
Thanks for the giveaway! These books look great!
Lemon chess pie is a famliy favorite. Can't. Wait to try this just found this on pinterest. I can never pick a favorite but I have never made bad item from the China moon cookbook they. Are complicated but worth it.
My favorite cookbook is the Fannie Farmer cookbook, I taught myself how to cook when I was 13 using my mothers beat up copy! It's still my go to cookbook!
Lruppert1@yahoo.com
My current fav book, I jsut receeived it for Christmas, is Momofuku bakery's Milk book, Cristina makes some crazy concoctions that taste like childhood memories!
Mary DeBorde
zenrei57 (at) hotmail dot com
I wish I could have a big piece of that gorgeous pie – haven't had a genuine chocolate chess pie in years!!! <3
My favorite cook book is a vintage one, with just a dash of humor, called The I Hate To Cook Book by Peg Bracken!
Love her illustrations, and love this sweet giveaway 🙂
MARY DEBORDE
And I subscribed via email:
zenrei57 (at) hotmail dot com
Happy New Year <3
The pie looks amazing….and what a diverse lineup of books. I actually want to read every one of them!
My favorite craft is knitting on my Looms. 🙂
I also subscribed via email, paige dot hall at gmail dot com. And I got so excited I forgot to mention my favorite cookbooks–Joy of Cooking for great basics that are easily modified, and Veganomicon, because it makes eating vegan so dang tasty!
My favorite is Mennonite Country-Style Recipes & Kitchen Secrets.
rsgrandinetti@yahoo(DOt)com
For sure my favorite garden is my mothers garden. As children we worked in it. As young adults we talked in it and now our young children play and eat berried to their hearts content with Grandma and Papa. In a place that was once hours of grounding there is a great joy. My kids and their cousins looks forward to spring in the dirt….and yes, so do I
My favorite garden was our garden this last year. We grew tomatoes, various squash, cucumbers, okra and lots of herbs. It turned out so well. I was amazed. Can't wait to do it again.
michelletucker at baconnation dot net
Follow via email (confirmed)
michelletucker at baconnation dot net
Our herb garden is my favorite garden around our house. We also have a strawberry patch which is pretty cool, too.
My favorite cookbook isnt really a cookbook. its a bunch of handwritten cards and scraps of paper from my grandmother that have general directions and very few real measurements.The only thing bookish about it is that I've put them all in a binder along with a few of my moms.
My cookbook I like is America's Test Kitchen I use it often.
mightynaynay(at)cs.com
We are just getting to where we are making unique recipes. We would love to try new ideas. Thank you
candieluster(at)gmail(dot)com
already subscribed…
i love the joy of cooking, it's my favorite
My favourite cookbook is The Joy of Cooking. I've owned a copy for over 30 years, and it has helped me learn so many basic recipes and cooking techniques over the years.
I like the cooking for 2 book my mom gave me, and I find a nice bunch of recipes on pinterest too
I love my mom's recipe book because it has recipes that she cut out since her childhood.
i love smitten kitchen's cook book. i just discovered your blog through pinterest. love it! i added you my reader 🙂
This pie looks SO decadent and amazing! The cookbook selection is fabulous… My all-time favorite cookbooks are the America's Test Kitchen books because I refer to them ALL the time.
Sues
My favorite cook book is The World Famous Purefoy Hotel Cook Book by Eva B. Purefoy. Given to me by my Grandmother,It is stained with memories of wonderful dishes I have cooked. It contains a deliciously easy version of a Pecan Pie that I always cook for Thanksgiving.
Did you paint the border with egg because putting the rope on top? It will help stick. It looks fantastic anyway!
Hello! Your braided edge may not sink if you preheat the oven to about 425. Then, as soon as you place the pie inside, turn it down to the temperature the recipe calls for. It may help "set" the crust in place better. (But, in this case, I LOVE the way it looks when it has fallen into the pan! It's beautiful!)
Hope this helps, and I cannot wait to try this recipe! It looks delicious!
Thank you so much Kimmy! I will try that the next time I attempt a braided crust 🙂
I tried this recipe and I almost didn't because I thought the addition of the corn meal was so odd. Cornmeal, really? However, the photos looked so scrumptious that I decided, what the heck. I'm so glad I did. It's not only a keeper but it reminds me so much of the chocolate pies my Aunt Lilla used to make make for family and for sale in the small community where I grew up. You see, Aunt Lilla developed Alzheimer’s disease and died before anyone could get the recipe … or she was too stubborn to share it. (It could have been both.) I can't wait to share this recipe on my blog!
subscribed!
Hello:
My favourite garden is and English style garden.
I have subscribe to your post. Will be making your pie tomorrow.
Have a Joyful Day :~D
Charlie
My favorite little cookbook is a simple spiral one I bought in NOLA years ago. It's called, "My Dead Daddy's Cajun Cookbook". Hahaha! Best gumbo recipe ever and I love the way she explains the importance of a good roux. My other favorite treasure isn't a cookbook… But, my Gran's old recipe box.
Very good. Reminiscent of a wonderful chocolate chess pie I used to get at a bakery in Graham North Carolina. Very rich and nice for the Holidays in place of cheesecake.
Let's Be Penpals!
from my homestead to your inbox